Skip ahead to the page itself

Review guidelines

The reviews that help most come from people who were there, say exactly what happened and keep it fair. These rules cover everyone who writes here, and every business too.

What a helpful review looks like

  • You were there. Within the past few years or so, you bought something from them, hired them, made a booking or asked them for a quote.
  • It gets specific. What did you buy, or what did they do for you? Was the final price the one you were quoted? Did it show up, or get finished, when promised? How did they deal with a problem? Details like these help the next customer far more than adjectives do.
  • It’s fair. Say what happened and how they treated you. Strong opinions are fine; insults aren’t.
  • Long enough, not too long. Aim for at least 40 characters; the cap is 3,000.

What stays off the site

  • Anything written by an employee, a relative of someone there, a competitor, or a person either of them pays.
  • Reviews written for a discount, a gift, money, a chance in a drawing or any other reward.
  • Reviews of some other business, or ones that are really about a manufacturer, a marketplace seller or a payment company rather than the business itself.
  • A second review of the same business from the same person within 30 days.
  • A web address, a phone number or an email, or any staff member’s full name or contact info.
  • Anything threatening, harassing, hateful or sexual, and swearing directed at somebody.
  • Writing lifted from another source, or churned out by an AI tool rather than drawn from your own experience.
  • Claims that someone broke the law. Report those to the police or the proper agency; you’re still free to describe your own experience.

What businesses can and can’t do

A business is welcome to ask every one of its customers for a review. What it can’t do is:

  • Offer something in return for a review, or only for a good one.
  • Ask only its happy customers, or talk unhappy ones out of writing.
  • Post reviews of their own place or a rival’s, whether they write them or hand the job to staff, relatives or an agency.
  • Lean on a reviewer, or threaten one, to get a review changed or taken down.

Every one of these rules matches the FTC’s rule on consumer reviews (16 CFR Part 465), and a review a business got by breaking them comes down.

If we turn your review down

A moderator reads every review written on Shop Talk before it goes live. When we reject one, we write down why. If you think we made the wrong call, contact us with the business’s name and the email address you used, and we’ll take another look.