Skip ahead to the page itself

How it all works

From the moment you hit post to the score beside a business's name, here's what happens, and what a business can and can't do about it.

How a review goes up

  1. You write it on Shop Talk, and it waits as pending. Until a moderator passes it, it doesn’t show on the business’s page and doesn’t count toward its score.
  2. Next, one of our moderators holds it up against the review guidelines and decides whether it goes live or gets turned away.

Along the way, the moderator checks a few things:

  • That it’s about a real, first-hand dealing with that business: something you ordered or booked, a visit, or a quote.
  • Anything that could reach or hurt a person gets stripped out: web links, phone numbers, private details about employees, threats and hateful language.
  • Whether one person is posting again and again, or whether the review came from the business’s own staff or a competitor.
  • That the same person hasn’t already reviewed that business in the last 30 days. One review per business every 30 days is the limit.

Businesses can answer any review where everyone can see it. They can’t edit a review, hide it or delete it, and no payment changes how one is handled. A one-star review goes up under exactly the same rules as a five-star one.

The math behind a score

A business’s score is the average of the stars in its published reviews, rounded to one decimal place. That’s all it is: nothing estimated, nothing weighted by who pays, nothing adjusted by hand.

The score takes on a color once a business has 5 published reviews. Before that you still see the number, in grey and marked as still new, since a handful of reviews can tip either way.

WordAverageOn the page
Terrific4.5 – 5.04.7
Pretty good4.0 – 4.44.2
Just OK3.0 – 3.93.4
Not great2.0 – 2.92.5
Awfulunder 2.01.6

Two scores: purchases and service

Reviewers tell us whether they bought something, asked for a quote or had work done. Once enough of them have answered, a business shows two separate scores, one for purchases and one for service, since plenty of places are good at one and not the other.

The details, and the bill

Reviewers can also rate straight answers, fair prices, how easy the business was to deal with, and quality. They can say whether the final bill matched the quote and whether any charges were sprung on them. None of these shows up until 5 customers have answered it.

Lists sorted by rating

When a list is sorted by rating, the order also weighs how many reviews each business has, so a newcomer with three five-star reviews doesn’t leapfrog a business that has earned forty great ones. Each business starts out with 5 make-believe reviews at 3.5 stars, and its real reviews pull it toward its true average as they come in:

rank = (3.5 × 5 + total stars received) ÷ (5 + review count)

This only sets the order of lists. On a business’s own page you always see the simple average.

Where reviews come from

Posted by the customer right here on Shop Talk
The customer typed it in on this site.
From a feedback form the business sends its own customers
The business gathered it from its own customers and sent it to us. We never take feedback the business picked out, edited or paid for.
From another review site
The customer wrote it on a different review platform, and we show it the way it was published there.

How we build listings

We build each listing from business details we gather and check: the name, address, phone number and website. If a business closes, or we can’t confirm a listing anymore, we hide it rather than delete it, so its reviews aren’t lost.

Owners can take over their page at no cost, then correct what’s wrong and reply to customers. Taking it over has no effect on the score.

Spotting a bad review

Every review has a Flag this link. Use it when a review breaks our guidelines, is about the wrong business, or doesn’t seem genuine to you. A moderator looks at every flag, then keeps the review, removes it, or asks the reviewer for more details. A flagged review stays up while we look into it.